It's (Barely) Legal (Glen Ashman's Blog)

A Look at the Law from a Georgia Judge and lawyer

Click the picture to visit Personal Law Forum and Ask a Lawyer for Free
About Glen Ashman
Glen (GEAATL)Glen Ashman has been a Georgia Municipal Court Judge since 1988 and an attorney since 1980, practicing in the Atlanta area in a practice focused on divorce, adoption, bankruptcy, wills, and personal injury.  He is the author of the Georgia Municipal Judges Benchbook, used by judges across the state.  He is a long-time participant in the online world, hosting some of the longest lived forums on Delphi Forums. His Personal Law and Southern States forums date to the mid 1990s.  He also hosts the Medical Forum, Weight Watchers Forum, Atlantic States and What's Happening on Delphi and is a former member of DelphiForums staff.  His Ask a Lawyer for Free is one of the oldest legal help resources on the internet.  He is a cum laude graduate of Mercer Law School, where he was on the Law Review and holds a B.A. from Emory University.  His interests range from the law to politics, from cooking to sports, from science fiction to computers, and from music to travel.


 
 
About this Blog

Somewhere around 1980-1981 Glen Ashman first discovered the online world with local bulletin boards.  In the years ahead, he found GEnie, Delphi and NVN, as many bulletin board members discovered forums online.  By 1994, he was actively hosting online forums at Delphi Forums and NVN, the former of which were some of the internet's early online forums.   Links to some of his current forums appear in the Links section in this Blog.

Within a couple years the author had various web pages as well.   The current one is at www.glenashman.com .

Along came a new concept as we entered this century - blogs.  A blog is an interesting cross between web pages and web forums.  This one is a work in progress, as all new things are.  But there is a common theme back to 1980 that lives in this blog - communication, education, community, discussion, learning and growth online. 

This blog shares a mission that Glen's other websites do - education and help: letting the average person access legal services at a reasonable cost, learning how to do some of the needed legwork when one has a problem and learning more about the law as well as the world around us.

If you want to contact the author, email him at geaatl@msn.com .   He welcomes your comments and thoughts.   Or visit his website at http://www.glenashman.com .    His Delphi forums are accessible from the links section of this blog, and you're invited to visit Personal LawSouthern States, Weight Watchers Forum, Delphi Medical Forum  and Atlantic States .


Disclaimer and Legal Fine Print: 

Lawyers have to have disclaimers. Here's the one for this Blog. The contents of this page Copyright 2006-2007 by Glen Ashman.  All Rights Reserved.   External links on this page are supplied for your use and convenience but are serviced and provided by third parties, so we cannot be responsible for their accuracy and content. Trademarks used on this site belong to the respective trademark holders.   The information herein is not legal advice and unless you later retain him by written contract, Glen Ashman is not your lawyer.  If you have a legal problem, you need to hire a lawyer in your state rather than rely on online information.

Current Poll
Do you have a will? (All Americans should have one)


Calendar
«November 2008»
SMTWTFS
2627282930311
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30123456
11/18/08 10:43 PM

Is Chief Justice Roberts Bored?

Chief Justice Roberts Adds a Touch of Noir to His Dissent
Legal Times

Is Chief Justice John Roberts Jr. already getting bored with traditional opinion-writing? Or, as one mystery writer and former attorney speculates, could he have lost a bet to Justice Antonin Scalia? In an extraordinary dissent from a Supreme Court denial of review issued in a fairly routine drug arrest case, Roberts starts off with two paragraphs that hark back to the best, or worst, of the hard-boiled mystery genre. Just one of the more memorable passages: "The neighborhood? Tough as a three-dollar steak."
http://www.law.com/jsp/article.jsp?id=1202425273996

 

Chief Justice's Noir-Tinged Dissent Gets Mixed Reviews
Legal Times

It appears that not all bloggers in the legal community are fans of hard-boiled detectives. Dissenting from the denial of review in a drug case, Chief Justice John Roberts Jr. included an introduction that recited the facts of the case in a classic noir style. But some bloggers have criticized Roberts' tone, which they see as dismissive. The defendant's own attorney called the dissent "an interesting read," but objected to an "implication" that a street transaction is necessarily a drug deal.
http://www.law.com/jsp/article.jsp?id=1202425301960

 
11/11/08 9:55 PM

Today's Dumbest Criminals

All from today's AP newswire:

Man calls cops but leaves pot pipe in plain sight   AP

SHEBOYGAN, Wis. - A 28-year-old man reporting a burglary faces drug charges after responding officers say they found a marijuana pipe in his bedroom. A criminal complaint filed Tuesday said officers saw the pipe in plain view in Justin Luecke's bedroom and found marijuana stems and seeds in the living room.

Police say robber was really caught 'red handed'  AP

LAWRENCE, Mass. - Police in Massachusetts say they caught a bank robber red handed — literally. On Monday, a man gave tellers a note threatening that he had a gun at a Sovereign Bank branch in Lawrence. Bank employees managed to hide a dye pack in the cash the robber stole.

Police say man sped away after handing over ID AP

PORTSMOUTH, N.H. - Police said it wasn't the most well-thoughtout escape. They say a man handed over his license and registration at a sobriety checkpoint during the weekend, then peeled out and sped away, almost hitting an officer.

Ark. police: Burglars sold silver ingot for $30 AP

BENTONVILLE, Ark. - The proprietor of a metal recycling business was suspicious of the group of young people who wanted to sell him a 62.5-pound chunk of metal, so he convinced them it was only lead and gave them $30 for it. It was really a silver ingot — worth $15,000. And the metals dealer called police.

Littering bust lands man in jail on drug charges AP

LAWRENCEVILLE, Ga. - Police said a man likely wishes he never threw trash on a highway. That's because littering wasn't the only charge filed against him. The man, 42, faces drug charges after deputies seized six pounds of methamphetamine from his vehicle.



 
11/6/08 11:52 PM

Today's dumbest criminals

Victim drives sleeping rapist to police station Wed Nov 5, 10:15 AM ET

WELLINGTON (Reuters) - A New Zealand rape victim drove her rapist to a police station when he fell asleep in his car after assaulting the woman, local media reported on Wednesday.

 

Teen arrested breaking into police station Mon Nov 3, 12:32 PM ET

SYDNEY (Reuters) - The long arm of the law didn't have to reach too far to arrest one Australian teen-ager, who was caught breaking into a police station in the early hours of Monday.

 

Alleged drunk driver thinks he's driving his car Thu Nov 6, 4:23 AM ET AP

FAIRBANKS, Alaska - A North Pole man was surprised when police accused him of stealing a car from a gentlemen's club in Fairbanks.

 

 

 
11/2/08 12:40 AM

Federal judge solicited prostitutes

10th Circuit Drops Judicial Conduct Probe of Former Federal Judge
The National Law Journal

The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has dropped its judicial
conduct investigation of U.S. District Judge Edward W. Nottingham of
the District of Colorado, who was accused of soliciting prostitutes
and spending thousands of dollars at a topless nightclub. Nottingham,
who was appointed by President George H.W. Bush in 1989, resigned on
Wednesday. The next day, Chief Judge Robert H. Henry dropped the
investigation, stating that the complaints filed against the judge
were "moot," given his resignation.

http://www.law.com/jsp/article.jsp?id=1202425690409

=======================

 
Federal judge in Colo. resigns amid investigation AP - Tue Oct 21, 6:34 PM ET

DENVER - The federal judge who oversaw the insider trading trial of former Qwest Communications CEO Joe Nacchio is resigning as complaints of judicial misconduct are investigated.  Edward W. Nottingham, the chief federal district judge in Colorado ceased his judicial duties immediately and his resignation will be effective Oct. 29, according to a statement Tuesday posted on the Web site of the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. The statement said multiple complaints of misconduct were being investigated by the circuit's judicial council. It did not elaborate. Judge Wiley Y. Daniel succeeds Nottingham as chief judge.

 
10/28/08 10:29 PM

Typos and Errors Lead to Slashed Fees


The Legal Intelligencer

Submitting a pleading riddled with typos and other errors has cost an attorney some big bucks. A federal judge spent three pages describing the errors, and ultimately slashed the $180,000 in requested fees to about $26,000. The attorney said in an interview that he relies too heavily on spell-checking software and that he accidentally filed an unproofed draft while using an electronic filing system. Among the misspellings flagged by the judge: "plaintf," "attoreys," "reasonbale" and "Ubited States."

http://www.law.com/jsp/article.jsp?id=1202425104538

 
10/6/08 11:26 PM

Forget the lawyers. Let the jury ask.

An evolving trend is to let jurors participate in trials.   Some stories on this change:

From 2000:

From American Lawyer Media

"What? A jury ask someone on the stand questions? Unbelievable. But in a
case of first impression, two judges of the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of
Appeals approved the practice of letting jurors in criminal cases submit
questions for witnesses."

Details:
http://www.law.com/cgi-bin/nwlink.cgi?ACG=ZZZ25XRITCC

--------------------------

From 2003:

JURORS MAY QUESTION WITNESSES, COURT SAYS
Associated Press

Trial courts can let jurors question witnesses, the Ohio Supreme Court
said Wednesday in a unanimous ruling. A trial judge may accept written
questions from jurors and pass them on to witnesses, without infringing
on defendants' rights, the high court said. "The practice of allowing
jurors to question witnesses provides for a two-way communication
through which jurors can more effectively fulfill their fundamental
role as fact finders," wrote Chief Justice Thomas Moyer.

http://news.findlaw.com/ap/o/1110/6-11-2003/20030611080006_16.html

Read The Opinion (State v. Fisher)
http://www.ohlawyersweekly.com/archives/oh/opin/sup/2761.htm

-----------------------------

From 2005:

Colo. Court Considers Juror Questions AP - Sat Apr 30, 4:11 PM ET

DENVER - The relatively new practice of allowing jurors to submit questions for witnesses during criminal and civil trials, upheld elsewhere in the country in federal courts, is facing a new legal test before Colorado's highest court.

------------------------------

When Jurors Run the Show
New Jersey Law Journal

Try to imagine defense counsel's dilemma as a plaintiff's expert, answering jurors' questions, takes over the trial. The witness proceeds to expound, lecture and even stride the courtroom floor -- sometimes even straying from his area of expertise. Does the defense keep silent? Or object and thereby risk alienating the jurors? It's a quandary posed by the practice -- as seen in the latest New Jersey Vioxx trial -- of allowing juror questions, and there seem to be few guidelines to resolve it.
http://wwwlaw.com/jsp/article.jsp?id=1143725006150

----------------------------------

And from this past week:

Study: Juror Questions, Limits on Lawyer Presentations Enhance Jury Trial Process
The National Law Journal

A 7th Circuit Bar Association study that tested alternative trial concepts, including allowing jurors to ask questions of witnesses during trials and limiting presentations by lawyers, generally showed that the new techniques enhanced the jury trial process. The study took into account survey results from 434 jurors, 86 lawyers and 22 federal trial judges who were involved in 50 civil jury trials.
http://www.law.com/jsp/article.jsp?id=1202424834469

 

 

 

Comments (1)

10/2/08 11:17 PM

"a gang rape ... by a bunch of lawyers"

Client's 'Frivolous' Motion in Divorce Case Leads to Attorney Sanction
New York Law Journal

A judge has taken an attorney to task for standing "blindly behind" a matrimonial client's recusal motion and her "fifty-three page diatribe" against the court for rejecting her bid to relocate to Texas with her children. New York Supreme Court Justice Lewis J. Lubell hit the lawyer with a $2,500 sanction and ordered the client to pay some $7,200 in attorney fees. In a separate reply affidavit cited by the court, the client compared the proceedings before Lubell to "a gang rape ... by a bunch of lawyers."
http://www.law.com/jsp/article.jsp?id=1202424744136
 
10/1/08 7:27 AM

New software to copy DVDs

Studios Sue to Bar a DVD Copying Program
New York Times
By BRAD STONE Six major movie studios sued RealNetworks, the Seattle-based digital media company, on Tuesday over its new $30 software program

Movie Studios, RealNetworks Sue Each Other In DVD-Copying Dispute
InformationWeek
RealDVD software lets people rent DVDs from a legitimate video-rental store and build a library of copied movies without ever buying a DVD.

MPAA sues Real Networks over RealDVD – and has reason to be upset
TG Daily 
By Wolfgang Gruener Opinion – Real Networks and the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) have filed dueling lawsuits in US courts

 

 

 
9/28/08 11:13 PM

You can be jailed for having a blog

Italy Makes Blogging A 2 Year Jailable Offense

A Sicilian judge ruled earlier this year that blogging, under Italian law, is the same as publishing an unregistered newspaper. In Italy, publishing an unregistered newspaper is a crime of "stampa clandestina," and is punishable by large fines and/or jail. And so down went the first blogger.  He was noticed because he wrote unkind things about the Italian government.  A horrible legal precedent and basis for the ruling.  But by registering a blog, the blog would then be subject to all laws governing newspaper publishing which means the blogger could no longer freely write his or her thoughts.  And so it would no longer be a blog.  And especially there would be no right to criticize the government. 
Since the ruling, another blogger has been taken down.  Apparently there are those in the Italian government who have decided to run with this opportunity.

Read about this in The Register (UK)  26-Sep-08
Click here for a full story on this  

(The above information is courtesy of the Bonehead of the Week newsletter <BoneheadOfTheDayAward@yahoogroups.com>)

 

Comments (2)

  • Sep-28 - Glen (GEAATL)Swedish bloggers give MEP a kicking over media pluralism The A Register Jun 27, 2008 ... Sweden’s bloggers have blown a gasket over an Estonian MEP's proposal that they and their European kindred spirits should assume some kind of responsibility for their content, forcing the European parliament to rush out a statement saying there were no such plans on the table. If anything, the Swedish blogosphere’s hysterical and often personal attacks on Estonia’s Marianne Mikko, on the basis of some off-kilter reporting by mainstream Swedish media, might bolster those who think that a focus on standards amongst journalists and/or bloggers might not actually be a bad thing. Mikko’s report on media pluralism was adopted by the European Parliament Culture Committee almost a month ago, and suggests that there was a need to “clarify” the status of blogs and to “create legal safeguards for use in the event of lawsuits as well as to establish a right of reply”. http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/06/27...  Show Full Comment
  • Sep-28 - Glen (GEAATL)Italy isn't the only nation doing this: Only 10% of Chinese bloggers register with Government ... The Blog Herald Attempts by the Chinese government to force Chinese bloggers to register their blogs has failed, with only 430,000 Chinese bloggers registring with the country’s Information Ministry, representing around 10% of the estimatated number of blogs in China. http://www.blogherald.com/2005/06/06/only-10-of-chinese-bloggers-register-with-government /
9/25/08 9:18 PM

Fart at cop; go to jail

Charge dropped against man accused of passing gas AP - Thu Sep 25, 5:06 PM ET

CHARLESTON, W.Va. - A West Virginia man accused of passing gas and fanning it toward a police officer no longer faces a battery charge. The Kanawha County prosecutor's office requested that the charge be dropped against 34-year-old Jose Cruz.

 

©2008 Mzinga All Rights Reserved